Sep 10, 2008

Outside looking in.

I like this picture of Mike & me. We were at my sister Joanna's house in Salt Lake & just about ready to walk out the door for Ryan & Whitney's rehearsal dinner. My hair is tidy, my makeup is in place, I have a normal, relatively happy smile, & you can't see my pale legs... it works, right? It's a decent picture. I'm not being vain here though - just trying to prove a point, of sorts. For those of you who are privy to see Joanna's blog (it's private, thank goodness), you know that this isn't the only picture that she took of us on her back porch. There is another one, & it is bad. I mean, she's a really great photographer, but I look chubby. It's just not a flattering picture. I'm pretty sure I have a double chin to complete the look. It's one of those pictures that I'd never, ever put on my very own blog (despite the fact that Mike looks great). The simple reality is that I take hundreds of pictures every month (some including me, some not). Only a few are actually published. Most of those that are posted don't show the 6-inch scar I have under my neck that I've always been self-conscious of. Or the dark circles that always seem to be under my eyes thanks to being over-worked & over-stressed (thank you, Bare Minerals). The pictures I choose to post are exactly that - things that I choose to share with the people who keep up with the Manhattan Whitings.
.
It got me thinking more broadly...
.
For some reason, I've had multiple conversations with people (siblings, friends, etc) in the last week about the reality that is portrayed on blogs vs. real life. For the most part, it's all good things that we publish, right? I'm absolutely guilty of this. Very rarely do I write something that is truly raw & unfiltered. After talking with these different people over the last few days (all of whom are in very different circumstances), it's pretty clear to me that while blogs serve a really good purpose (& are a lot of fun), they also help to perpetuate a myth that we all live glamorous & perfect lives, complete with perfect husbands, perfect children, lovely friends, perfect jobs, complete with luxurious & frequent vacations. We're all wonderfully thoughtful (or our husbands are), incredibly creative, perfectly witty & yet appropriately humble. I mean, we're all seriously so blessed, right?
.
The fact of the matter is, more often than not, that just not the case, it's just not reality. Things are not always perfect, & oftentimes, life is kind of hard. Or maybe even really hard.
.
The fact that blogs only show the "good stuff" has the potential to make people (me included) feel depressed, inadequate or just plain boring at times. Maybe even jealous that someone has something or is someone that you wished you had or were. Or maybe it's just me that feels that way. Maybe I'm the only one who doesn't always feel 100% genuine, who is prone to only highlighting the good stuff. When I feel like I really can't be sincere, or I just don't feel like being super positive, I tend to retreat away from blogging- because I don't want to be fake, & I don't want to be insincere. It's a scary thing to have a flawed, published portrait of yourself & your life happenings, because that means that there is a written record of your (my) many imperfections or simply an account of the un-exotic details that oftentimes make up the daily grind.
.
If I have a point, I guess it's that I want to be more honest, but sometimes I find that it's really hard (maybe impossible?) to do. I have friends who are incredibly genuine & real (in person, & on the www) & I really respect & admire their "take me as I am" attitudes... I want to be there, too. Even if it means that some days I just complain only to vent (& that's okay), or maybe I want to highlight how unglamorous New York City really is at times (think extra stress & extra intensity, topped off with an extra pressure to really succeed- Did you know that I lose 8 years of life expectancy being a Manhattan resident?). Or maybe I should feel okay talking about some of those things that make me grow (recognition of my mistakes & many imperfections), or publishing a picture that is taken from a terrible angle but is still fun. I just want to try harder I guess, to achieve a better balance between being being positive, happy & hopeful (as I should be), while also portraying a realistic view of my life, as is.

16 comments:

Unknown said...

That is a great photo and I want your dress. It's so perfect.

I like these thoughts and think that everyone who blogs has probably thought the same thing. Unfortunately, my goal is the opposite- to NOT write the "truth" all the time when it focuses on the negative, but choose to share a bit of the parts of my life I love and make me better. (i.e. I think I'm too honest sometimes. It can be my setback.)

That said, I loved the very last bit of the NY TImes article on Stephanie Nielson. It talked about how POSITIVE she always was on her blog.. which drew in a readership that read what she wrote for an outlet (kind of like reverse Soap Opera). They say,

"...the legend only grows. But Supermom had her off days, too.

'People don’t understand that of course Stephanie had days where she was crazy and wanted to pull her hair out,' Ms. Kendrick said. 'Her relationship with her husband wasn’t perfect. But she chose to focus on the beauty.

'And the more she focused on it, the more she had.'"

That's what I want to share and live and have for myself- more beauty. The nitty gritty truth will be told to whoever who really knows me. Because I've never been one to hold that back. And for my posterity? Journals that not everyone needs to read. And of course some of that will all seep into my blog too (which I think is perfectly healthy. It's good to just talk). But I could do better with sharing and living and becoming the happy.

Unknown said...

I have to say though that I wouldn't post a bad photo of myself either. Actually, the last belly shot I posted looked horrible so I took it down, woke Brad up at 10pm and handed him the camera to take another. That one went up. :)

Jill said...

I am a fan of the positive spin, not changing reality, but focusing on the good. I understand wanting to be honest - a worthy goal. I'm also a fan of good-old fashion venting.

Bottom line for me, I don't need to compare my life to others, or to judge. If I find some one to be 'amazing' (no doubt because I'm comparing my short side to their long side) then I try to use them as an inspiration.

I love blogs because they help me to stay in touch with family and friends in a way I don't always get. It's a unique outlet.

suz said...

Very interesting post - it made me think

Meg said...

I LOVED THIS POST K! I was just talking to Joe about this the other night...how yes we only put positive things and I'm not sure how I am putting myself out there. That maybe I do need to complain and that it's ok to right what went wrong....to sum it up I just agree with you on this post. And I've been trying to figure out just how to write something like this on my blog. Oh and BTW... I LOVE LOVE the photo and the prefect dress that you have on.

Bri said...

This is a great post, Kathryn. Very true.

Anonymous said...

the first time i met you i liked how 'real' you were...remember our conversation about the goldman sax boys' club? i have many thoughts and feelings i often don't share (or share with a select few who i know really know me) for fear of being too negative...so i appreciate your post and insight. and you know what, you are GORGEOUS because you're actually kind of a nice person. :) that genuine kindness is hard to come by...

laurel said...

Hi Kathryn,

I saw your name and comment on Megan's blog today - so I thought I would drop in and say hello! I think I am either losing my mind or just really behind, but I thought you guys moved to CT? Anyway, looks like you are doing great!

Laurel

Heidi said...

First, that is a fabulous photo of you and Mike. You really do look beautiful.

So as you know I posted an awful phoot of myself a few days ago on my blog because I was having a pity party. ha. What you say here is absolutely true. I remember a literature class I took back in college (before blogs) and even before blogs people had journals where we all created our own narrative through writing and could portray who we want to be or wish to be throuhg that narrative. And those weren't open to public viewing but I think most people that had/have journals think someday some descendant of theirs will read it. So deep down they/we knew it would be read as well. Okay anyway, I have been printing my blog into books as family jorunals kind of and so usually I think I only want to post good photos and happy posts because that is what I want to remember in ten years when I look back on this. However, I also like the community that blogging has created and for that reason sometimes I vent and share the nitty gritty, because I feel like I have a support system of sorts and it helps to know others can relate or they are there to back me up or make me feel good. So that is my stance on what goes on my blog. I have to say I think no matter what you write though (no matter how awful) I will still always be in awe of your New York life and your glittering summer trips to the lake. Hm this comment just got way too long!

Kera said...

can you imagine if someone were to post something like "hello everyone, my husband just cheated on me and I drink in my closet at night, love you all"

Sine family said...

Well said K. Well said. For the record I'll take it all the good, the bad, and the crazy so feel free to blog about any of it and I'll still love you.

emily said...

I agree with you...here are my feelings about it: My blog is my family journal. I'm not going to write about petty arguments, but I will write about silly, funny, memorable, dumb things we do, in everyday life. NOT perfect world life. Who doesn't love to read back in an old journal about your thoughts and emotions at the time? You do a wonderful job on your blog. I love reading it. BLOG ON SISTER!

Lizzie said...

Interesting & good thoughts. And I love the dress :)

I agree, sometimes we tend to focus on the positives while blogging - but I think that's part of why I like it . . . I pay more attention to enjoying happy moments, fun times, or silly things. I take more pictures, think more creatively (and in essay form) and get a relief from writing my thoughts and stories down somewhere/anywhere.

However, I wouldn't be being honest if I didn't say that sometimes reading other blogs got me discouraged about my own life - but, most of the time, I am inspired by others blogs (or just enjoying the fun way of staying in touch with friends & fam).

So, I guess I see both sides. The need to be honest about self & life & reality (I could always do better with that), but also the part about the good that comes from focusing on the postives.

I really liked this post, it got me thinking.

ANYWAYS - Yes, please, let's meet up for lunch! I can do M, Tu, or F of next week!

k. said...

Oh my gosh, thanks for everyone's comments...

After some time to digest this, my point remains generally the same... albeit maybe a bit more clear. It is simply all about BALANCE. Not a confession of sins or problems via the www (not appropriate or a good idea), not trying to show that you have an absolutely perfect life at all time... (unrealistic & somewhat fake). It's about being balanced, with a positive spin. No one wants to be a Debbie Downer all the time, but I hope to strive for balance & reality. That's what I feel, but I guess since our blogs are most certainly personal, we all have our own choice in terms of what direction we want to go.

I love my friends.

Melissa said...

Thanks for this post...I agree completely! I love reading your blog...I think you do a great job keeping balance and keeping it real.

jocelyn said...

This post is so true. Blogs are like Christmas cards. Some are cute and tell you what they're up to and others are just braggadocios
and annoying. Thanks for you cupcake advice comment. I have made a mental note!